Evaluating teachers and quarterbacks

As a kid, I sort of cracked the code for the quarterback rating formula when I was in 4th grade or so.  If you’re interested in this story, you can check out my Learning a Hobby post.  I also had what I considered to be good and bad teachers throughout my school career.  I have spent a fair amount of time thinking about what makes teachers “good,” but I haven’t thought of this in terms of a formula.  Until now.

Here’s a graphic from an article in the New York Times (login to a free account is required):

This is interesting to me.  How do you measure and assign a value to “student characteristics”? Does a poor black kid living with his grandmother who makes him do his homework and be respectful to his elders count higher or lower than a kid who has two professional parents who will always side with their son because he, like them, is entitled to the best in life?  How do you measure “true total school effect”?  What is the “student error term”?  Subscripts, superscripts, Greek letters as variables and summations.  I don’t buy it.

Here’s how the NFL rates passers (per Wikipedia):

where mm(x) = max(0,min(x,2.375))

when

It’s not the subscripts, superscripts, Greek letters, and mathematical operations that make these two formulas fundamentally different, it’s the nature of the “data” and the interrelationships between the values that make one formula comprehensible and the other not for me.

In a 16 game regular season, an NFL quarterback may have a few passes where there is a difference of opinion as to whether it was caught or incomplete or intercepted.  A few touchdowns may be called back because of a penalty or some other factor.  But, by and large, there is wide acceptance to what it means to complete a pass, to attempt a pass, to intercept a pass, or to score a touch down.  There is an accepted method for measuring the distance gained when a pass is completed.  The commisioner, owners, players, coaches, referees, announcers, and fans share in this body of knowledge and pretty much accept the outcome when the final decision comes down.

Teaching and learning is not this calculable.  What works for one student may not work for another.  Not all kids have the same resources at home or at school.  Not all teachers have the same level of support from their principals.  Not all principals have access to a supportive central office or others who can help improve learning in their school.  Not all PTOs can raise the same dollar amounts.  Not all school libraries are powerful centers for meaning making.

Another thing that I find amazing in all of this is the notion of winning or losing a game regardless of how well the quarterback rated.  Having a perfect quarterback rating for a game does not guarantee victory, which is what really counts in the end.  Just ask Chad Pennington and Bobby Hebert – they both had perfect games according to the formula but walked away losers.  And, the highest rated quarterback doesn’t always make it to the playoffs.  How will this play out for our teacher rating formulas?

58 Responses to “Evaluating teachers and quarterbacks”

  1. Chris Frank Says:

    I love it! Do the algorithms have an opinion parameter? I’m just thinking if I had to rank people, the best way is to get other people’s opinions about them… students, parents, other teachers. It wouldn’t be perfect but it would be uncommon for a really good teacher to score low like this, or for a really bad teacher to score high. And ranking teachers should be easier than ranking pro quarterbacks. The difference between pro quarterbacks is tiny compared to differences between teachers. What would you do if you could invent the teacher ranking system?

  2. Guy Brandenburg Says:

    Chris, I think you have it exactly backwards. Ranking teachers is much harder than ranking quarterbacks. There are plenty of cases where a teacher who I really disliked nevertheless did a good job of teaching me stuff. In college, I found out the hard way that I could transfer out of classes with professors I disliked or had big political/moral disagreements with. But even the ones I strongly disliked, I learned something in their class. And the US Airforce Academy did an extremely valuable experiment in some of their classes (physics?) where they randomly assigned studednts to professors, for years, so the students couldn’t pick and choose the way i used to do. They found, very consistently,t hat professors who got the highest evaluations were the ones who were able to earn the highest grades for their students — grades largely being assigned by department-wide final exams and tests and so on — but those high-ranking professors by those short-term measures were, quite surprisingly to many folks — the absolute worst in promoting long-term understanding. And yes, this LTU was measured!!!So what do you want? Long-term understanding and poor grades and low student evalua5tions, or high grades and good testr scores and positive s5tudent evaluaions, coupled with a serious lack of thoughtful insight and long-5term understanding of the basic fundamental concepts of the discipline?

  3. health supplements Says:

    Thanks for the information. I plan to use this help help from getting spam on my blog.

  4. chick here Says:

    Let not your mind run on what you lack as much as on what you have already.

  5. healthy diabetic Says:

    This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. thank you very much. Feel free to visit my buy portfolio lighting site.

  6. click here Says:

    Did you know about Freelance writing job service? I wanted to tell that your ideas connecting to this good post is supreme! Thank you very much for creating it!

  7. Glasfiberflagstænger Says:

    Hi, just wanted to say I attended this conference last year, and found it by far the best of about 8 conferences that I attended in the field. Full of professional insight based on testing by experts that knew what they were talking about. I would certainly go again and recommend it to anyone operating in this field.

  8. dissertation writing service Says:

    To see and listen to the wicked is already the beginning of wickedness.

  9. kloak Århus Says:

    This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. thank you very much. Feel free to visit my buy portfolio lighting site.

  10. phd thesis writers Says:

    It’s clear that you really know this subject matter well. After reading other articles of this type, I was discouraged. I will walk away from your article with more knowledge.

  11. Carpet Cleaning in Austin Says:

    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

  12. trx suspension trainer sale Says:

    This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. thank you very much. Feel free to visit my buy portfolio lighting site.

  13. Discount TRX Says:

    Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such information.

  14. thesis outline writing Says:

    this blog is realy appreciated its realy good and this sight give great information i realy want to use this blog will u.

  15. Privathospitaler Says:

    I phoned my grandparents and my grandfather said ‘We saw your movie.’ ‘Which one?’ I said. He shouted ‘Betty, what was the name of that movie I didn’t like?

  16. Google Analytics Says:

    一个真正精湛的内容,对本网站的数量,把有关的贡献<a href="http://www.adhost.dk/kompetencer/google-analytics">Google Analytics</a>

  17. Seo Says:

    Thank you for this post. Thats all I are able to say. You most absolutely have built this blog website into something speciel. You clearly know what you are working on, youve insured so many corners.thanks

  18. Google Adwords Says:

    You can only perceive real beauty in a person as they get older.

  19. anlægsgartner Hillerød Says:

    Personally, I would sooner have written Alice in Wonderland than the whole Encyclopedia Britannica.

  20. Mother of the Bride Says:

    This post is beautiful and what a fantastic research you’ve done. It helped me a lot. Thank you. You are welcome to buy my lighting portfolio site.

  21. youtube views and subscribers Says:

    This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. thank you very much. Feel free to visit my buy portfolio lighting site.

  22. personal statement editing service Says:

    Let not your mind run on what you lack as much as on what you have already.

  23. press release writing services Says:

    Games are not only important in a sense that they enhance our muscular strenghth, they are e

  24. Seo Says:

    运行一个博客后的另一个奇妙的职位!许多感谢,因此采取了很多时间来分享一个人的信息和智慧与其他作家一起。

  25. Buy twitter followers Says:

    I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will locate that extremely useful

  26. seo Says:

    One other thing is that an online business administration study course is designed for individuals to be able to smoothly proceed to bachelors degree programs. The Ninety credit education meets the lower bachelor diploma requirements then when you earn your current associate of arts in BA online, you will possess access to up to date technologies in such a field. Several reasons why students need to get their associ

  27. custom essay writing Says:

    Shopping means to buy things. It could be of anything. This website deals with the shopping of hair accessories. You can buy any of these online.

  28. tax attorney Says:

    I was about to say something on this topic. But now i can see that everything on this topic is very amazing and mind blowing, so i have nothing to say here. I am just going through all the topics and being appreciated. Thanks for sharing.

  29. stryker hip recall Says:

    what i was thinking is first i want to learn that equation and do the math well i have to research my books for this so i can get more comfortable during doing this blog…

  30. Central Austin Foreclosures Says:

    Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such information.

  31. financial base Says:

    It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I’m sure you had fun writing this article.Excellent entry! I’m been looking for topics as interesting as this. Looking forward to your next post.

  32. Austin Real Estate Says:

    Nice post…I look forward to reading more, and getting a more active part in the talks here, whilst picking up some knowledge as well..

  33. language translations Says:

    Did you know about Freelance writing job service? I wanted to tell that your ideas connecting to this good post is supreme! Thank you very much for creating it!

  34. language translation service Says:

    I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will locate that extremely useful

  35. Buy Nopalea drink Says:

    Very good sum, I like to solve mathematics sum. It is my hobby.

  36. islamic banking writers Says:

    I think there is no harm to share such awesome stuff on every good website….

  37. firme offshore Says:

    An interesting discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write more on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but generally people are not enough to speak on such topics.

  38. thesis writing service in malaysia Says:

    This looks absolutely perfect. All these tinny details are made with lot of background knowledge. I like it a lot. Keep on taking action!

  39. best application essays Says:

    Correction: The original version of this article stated that some U.S. Department of Agriculture certified organic products may contain neotame. Since the publishing of this article, NaturalNews has obtained a letter from the USDA’s National Organic Progr

  40. Willis Custom Homes Says:

    oakley radar range Such a horrible wound, Dr Tam has no fear, concentrate on the treatment, so stand Zheng moved. ry32cvb

  41. Webshop Says:

    You can’t really say what is beautiful about a place, but the image of the place will remain vividly with you.

  42. Austin Texas Homes For Sale Says:

    bot, however, is not aware of CSS. So, it thinks that it really is part of the form and will fill something in. So, if there is something in this field, it must have been filled in by a bot, so the post is discarded.

  43. Austin Texas Homes For Sale Says:

    bot, however, is not aware of CSS. So, it thinks that it really is part of the form and will fill something in. So, if there is something in this field, it must have been filled in by a bot, so the post is discarded.

  44. Austin Homes For Sale Says:

    Are you sure these methods are really woring for you? I’m glad they don’t but I’m just asking.. But the stuff you recommend definately work so for everyone out there who are doubting. Don’t!

  45. buy cheap facebook fans Says:

    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

  46. Glarmester Aarhus Says:

    I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own Blog Engine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it…..

  47. servicii seo Says:

    Your blog article is very interesting and fantastic, at the same time the blog theme is unique and perfect, great job. To your success. One of the more impressive blogs I’ve seen. Thanks so much for keeping the internet classy for a change.

  48. high school essay writing Says:

    IT stands for Information Technology. The major role of information technology is to spread information through out the world. Tv, mobile phone and internet are the mentionable gadgets of IT. Internet is a way in which thousands of computers are interconnected throughout the world and share their information.

  49. Termoruder Aarhus Says:

    This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. Thank you very much. Feel free to visit my buy portfolio lighting site.

  50. Law Essay Writing Says:

    Thanks for the tips, maybe I can use this ended my tufted marketing and I’ve been use untold anulus media in run a interaction and they someone existing a big amend on me.

  51. casino spelen Says:

    oakley radar range Such a horrible wound, Dr Tam has no fear, concentrate on the treatment, so stand Zheng moved. ry32cvb

  52. Austin Custom Home Builders Says:

    The real sin against life is to abuse and destroy beauty, even one’s own even more, one’s own, for that has been put in our care and we are responsible for its well-being.

  53. essay editing services Says:

    A good blog always comes-up with new and exciting information and while reading I have feel that this blog is really have all those quality that qualify a blog to be a good one

  54. http://focus4development.ca Says:

    A bot, however, is not aware of CSS. So, it thinks that it really is part of the form and will fill something in.

  55. onlinemarketingcanada.ca Says:

    Thank you for this post. Thats all I are able to say. You most absolutely have built this blog website into something speciel. You clearly know what you are working on, youve insured so many corners.thanks

  56. www.studio-six.com Says:

    bot, however, is not aware of CSS. So, it thinks that it really is part of the form and will fill something in. So, if there is something in this field, it must have been filled in by a bot, so the post is discarded.

  57. santa1 Says:

    At most levels, but especially at the college and professional level, the quarterback role is the most visible and important role on the team. The quarterback touches the ball on nearly every offensive play and has a great deal of responsibility both in calling plays and making decisions during the play. Thanks.<a href="http://www.bestcollegeessays.org/our-services/college-entrance-essays/">entrance essays for college</a>

  58. ellyhower Says:

    Thank you a lot for providing individuals with such a memorable opportunity to read from this site. It’s always very ideal and as well , full of a great time for me personally and my office mates to visit your blog at least 3 times a week to learn the newest guidance you have. And of course, I’m actually fascinated concerning the cool advice you give. Certain 4 points in this post are basically the most effective I have ever had.<a href="http://www.writemyessays.org/">Write My Essays</a>

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: